| All-Americans | Year |
|---|---|
| Scott Downing | 1991 |
| All-Midwest | Year |
|---|---|
| Scott Downing | 1991 |
| Kris Barney | 2001 |
| Adam Smith | 2003 |
| Ryan Pignatiello | 2012 |
| 1st Team All-State | Year |
|---|---|
| Scott Downing | 1990 |
| Scott Downing | 1991 |
| Whitney Gibson | 1995 |
| Brad Gibson | 2000 |
| Kris Barney | 2001 |
| Adam Smith | 2003 |
| Cullen Baron | 2011 |
| Ryan Pignatiello | 2012 |
| Ryan Kagy | 2013 |
| Mitchell Colvin | 2016 |
| Caiden Smith | 2017 |
| Matt Hinkle | 2019 |
| Owen Hadden | 2020 |
| Evan Stonerock | 2021 |
| Carson King | 2023 |
| 2nd Team All-State | Year |
|---|---|
| Joe Downing | 1987 |
| Jason Miller | 1988 |
| Trevor Baron | 2004 |
| Michael Porto | 2005 |
| Jarod Weaver | 2007 |
| Ben Shaw | 2008 |
| Matt Gioiello | 2009 |
| Mitchell Colvin | 2015 |
| Zach Bonifas | 2016 |
| Michael Pfister | 2018 |
| Ben Sauls | 2019 |
| Johnny Baileys | 2020 |
| Carson King | 2022 |
| Caleb Ransom | 2022 |
| Landon Haas | 2023 |
| 3rd Team All-State | Year |
|---|---|
| Brody Danner | 1992 |
| Andrew Moore | 1993 |
| Whitney Gibson | 1994 |
| Adam Smith | 2002 |
| Michael Porto | 2004 |
| 4th Team All-State | Year |
|---|---|
| Shaun Hodges | 1984 |
| Nathan Dix | 1996 |
